Terrie's Take 909 (Tourism Edition) - DMOs, Action, and Authenticity - A Tourism Recipe for Remote Prefectures
terrie at mailman.japaninc.com
Mon Aug 14 08:52:30 JST 2017
* * * * * * * * TERRIE'S (TOURISM) TAKE - BY TERRIE LLOYD * * * * * *
A bi-weekly focused look at the tourism sector in Japan, by Terrie
Lloyd, a long-term technology and media entrepreneur living in Japan.
Tourism Sector Edition Sunday, Aug 13 2017, Issue No. 909
SUBSCRIBE to, UNSUBSCRIBE from Terrie's Take at:
+++ DMOs, Action, and Authenticity - A Tourism Recipe for Remote Prefectures
One of the major reasons I got into the travel business was the
opportunity to not just sell tours and entertainment, but to work at a
deeper level, helping remote regions to improve their infrastructure and
attractiveness, and thus help those areas bring home some tourist
dollars. With the continuing migration of Japanese youth from country
areas to the major cities, the only thing that will keep those kids
nearer to home is if they are able to pursue a worthwhile career and
support their own families.
And so while I'm very focused on building the www.japantravel.com
business, I nonetheless try to reserve some extra time and energy to
find and assist regional areas willing to make the conceptual leap
between just wishing for foreign tourist income and actually doing
something about it. Not that the regional areas have not been trying. In
recent years, both through both central government largesse and through
local desperation, billions of yen have been spent on websites, videos,
photos, and translation - but which even if people view them, seldom
result in the tangible result of more foreign tourists.
Why? because even though such prefectures may be wonderful places, the
fact is that they are usually too remote and lack the wow factor needed
to draw foreign tourists the extra hundreds of kilometers away from the
usual ports of entry and proven tourist favorites. The cost of JR rail
tickets and domestic airfares also doesn't help.
Earlier this year I had the opportunity to propose a deep project to a
certain northern territory that is remote from Tokyo and which is not
directly serviced by western airlines (they have two infrequent Chinese
air routes and one Korean air service). The area has all the right
components for a tourism industry - remote rugged coastline, hiking
trails and climbable mountains, apples and other bounty of the land,
ancient villages and bucolic countryside hamlets. But while it has all
these things, with the exception of one festival, no one point is
outstanding enough to pull the foreign tourist in preference to other
more convenient places with the same attractions. For example, if you
want nature and you're entering at Tokyo, Tochigi fits the bill and is
just 100km away. If you're entering at Sapporo, then you have the
breadbasket of Japan at your doorstep, so why travel further?
------- Kurashinity Housekeeping Service, by Pasona -------
"Kurashinity" is an affordable, top-tier housekeeping service produced
by Japan's leading human resource company, Pasona Inc.
Kurashinity provides skilled Filipina housekeepers who are hospitable,
professional, and trained to maintain the cleanliness of your lovely
home. Packages start with two-hour cleaning sessions twice a month for a
1LDK apartment and three-hour cleaning sessions twice a month for a 2LDK
location. Monthly packages start at a very reasonable ¥10,000. Why not
make your home sparkle today? Our current service areas are Tokyo and
E-mail: housekeeping at pasona.co.jp
Register at https://goo.gl/H8YJ1Z
As you might have guessed, the region is Aomori, a wonderful part of
Japan that attracts about millions of Japanese domestic tourists (35m
room nights) with its distinctive scenery and cool-weather
fruit/vegetable harvests every year. But in contrast, the region last
year only received enough foreign tourists to have spent just 100,000
room nights there. Remember, that's room nights. So if you assume that
each person there for the Nebuta Matsuri (the peak attractant for
tourists in the area) is staying for at least 2-3 nights, then the
actual number of people traveling to Aomori is probably far less.
So how does Aomori combat the fact that it is being eclipsed by Hokkaido
to the north and by equally scenic locations to the south? Given that
the Nebuta festival is such a huge hit, maybe they should start another
festival? The problem here is that their inbound travel traffic already
clusters around the Nebuta event and as soon as it is over, the number
of visitors plummets. So, given the amount of effort and funds it would
need to start a second festival, the benefit to the area is still going
to be a short peak and empty hotel rooms for most of the rest of the
year - probably a poor return on investment. Better that they use the
Nebuta festival as an eye-catching marketing point, but after the
awareness level is raised, look to shifting visitors to other points of
Aomori, like so many other remote regions around Japan, needs to find
something it's good at and which can be delivered for at least 6-9
months a year. An attractant that takes advantage of their remoteness
and many kilometers of rugged coastline. Then once they have decided on
that main theme, they need to apply imagination, development funds, and
persistence to turn it into reality. My own proposal to Aomori was that
they should focus on becoming an adventure destination - on the basis
that if the experience is compelling enough, then the remote location
will become a blessing not a curse. Among the increasingly popular
sports overseas that people are traveling great distances to enjoy, are
hiking, cycling, kayaking, and mountain climbing -- all a good fit for
Aomori. (OK, and of course skiing and cross-country snow sports in the
It's not like these sports are not on the minds of the Aomori tourism
folks, indeed, it's kind of obvious. Rather, the challenge for them and
in fact for any prefectural government is the idea that they need to
move beyond just being an information provider. They need to dig into
the business infrastructure of their region and help lift the commercial
boats at the same time as telling the world what they have. I do find it
interesting that local governments all over the country are so shy in
getting involved in business, especially since this is the home of
"Japan Inc." Perhaps it's because of past incidents of collusion between
governments and business which subsequently became scandals. However,
now that we have the whole emerging trend of properly structured and
reported Public-Private Partnerships overseas, it seems that the
opportunity for collaboration between government and private business
has become appropriate once again. And of course this is a big
contributing factor to the rise of Destination Management Organizations
(DMOs) around the country.
http://bit.ly/2fCUHIq [Definition of DMO]
If Japanese local governments can get themselves motivated to help
fund/administer a ground shift in inbound tourism investment, then what
needs to happen is the following:
a) They need to invest in tourism projects that are meaningful
multi-year efforts, rather than the current light-weight one-year budget
periods. I don't understand why local governments are allergic to
long-term commitments. Maybe the new DMOs will fix this.
b) They need to create infrastructure that is geared to tourism rather
than local constituents' practical needs - such as cycle ways, campsites
in remote areas, and upkeep of tracks for non-locals to trek through.
c) They need to continue their financial and administrative involvement
beyond mere creation and promotion of travel information - instead
focusing on creating a public-private technology ecosystem whereby local
merchants can build resources, upload and market their inventory in real
time, run their actual operations in the cloud, and accept foreign
payments from a diverse range of cards and payment methods.
d) They need to create a business loans environment that lets local
merchants invest with confidence in more rooms, more attractions, better
facilities, beautification, and infrastructure. The most practical move
would be to offer guarantees and loans backing to local banks as well as
to some regional venture capital investors (some prefectures such as
Fukuoka and Sendai already have such VCs).
Moving to such a high level of involvement with the root operations of
tourism is certainly not second nature to local governments. And yet, if
they don't move into this role, then who will? Central government
funding all to often goes to the big corporations in Tokyo, and local
private sources of capital are so risk averse that for them there will
never be a time when foreign tourists will be important enough to lend
----- Gourmet Ride Event - Tohoku nature and flavors! -----
Two-day cycling tour in the beautiful countryside of Aomori and Iwate,
highlighted by gourmet cooking by famous chefs. Enjoy the bounty of
Honshu's northern region while enjoying the company of other cyclists
and local hosts. Learn more and join us!
Dates: Saturday 30th September thru' Sunday 1st October, tours include a
one-night stay at an onsen.
Details & Registration: http://or-waste.com/?p=22
Date: Saturday 14th October
Details & Registration: URL will be decided mid-August.
These events are hosted by The Cuisine Press Inc., email us:
jointheaction at or-waste.com
There are some other parts of Japan which have created an image for
themselves that has not only overcome the remoteness of their locations,
but in fact has enhanced the romantic association that such remoteness
lends. Take, for example, the Nakasendo pilgrimage route in the Kiso
Valley (Gifu Prefecture), which now draws thousands of wealthy foreign
tourists to such small towns as Magome and Tsumago. There was a time not
so long ago, that this area was unknown and overlooked by foreigners.
But thanks to the persistence and end-to-end efforts of tourism
companies overseas to make the journey a vivid trip back into history,
the idea has caught on. There was no DMO involved, but it is a great
example of how "content" trumps distance.
Another good example is the Minakami area which has become an extreme
sports haven in central Japan. Originally based on the efforts of one
Kiwi-led company, Mike Harris' Canyons, the Tone river is now ground
zero for whitewater rafting and canyoning adventures in Japan. 20 years
ago there was just one operator on the river carrying maybe half a dozen
rafts a day, now there are multiple operators with 10 times as many
rafts and passengers. The whitewater rafters of course need something to
do in the afternoons, and so now bungy jumping, canyoning, and
paragliding are becoming popular in the area as well.
What Aomori can learn from the DMOs and Nakasendo and Minakami is that
if you mix experience-related investment with action and a multi-day
course, people WILL travel to even remote locations to enjoy an
experience they can't get elsewhere. Just like they travel to
Disneyland. As with both of these locations, you need a mix of dedicated
local merchants who are willing to create services that match the
environments they are based in, and who will push to envelope to ensure
that the experiences are not smothered with too much Japanese
over-control, or by poorly developed surroundings. Modern tourists
willing to travel far for an experience also want that experience to
feel authentic. If they are riding a wild river, it really does need to
be wild, and not tamed with concrete. If they are seeking a piece of
history, you'd better try to get rid of the power poles and cheap
post-war prefabs that otherwise despoil a special location.
I don't know if Aomori will buy into my proposal, which in any case is
only a small part of what needs to be done. But I can say that if they
and other equally remote prefectures don't make the effort, then due to
their lack of natural gifts like spectacular mountains or volcanoes,
they will be doomed to a tourism future of mediocrity. Which would be a
sad thing, given that the people, the food, and the existing scenery are
pure Japan - service-oriented, wholesome, and memorable. Just they need
the value added content that creates the experience that people want
badly enough they'll travel long distances to enjoy it.
...The information janitors/
----- SHOCHU & AWAMORI Taste the Spirit of Japan 2017 -----
Discover the charm of Japanese spirits! On Sep 4 at Togo Kinenkan, a
variety of Japanese craft liquors will be presented, with information,
at a special event. Tasting opportunities available.
Free attendance; registration required.
------------- Office Admin Position Open ------------------
Japan Partnership Inc. is urgently seeking an Administration Coordinator
to help run its small but dynamic international media business in the
heart of Tokyo that publishes Japan's number 1 English magazine,
Metropolis. Preference is for someone who is E/J bilingual but at least
native in Japanese with some English capability.
Interested applicants should email neil at metropolisjapan.com for details
SUBSCRIBERS: 6,446 members as of Aug 13, 2017 (We purge our list regularly.)
+++ ABOUT US
Written by: Terrie Lloyd (terrie.lloyd at japaninc.com)
HELP: E-mail Terrie-request at mailman.japaninc.com with the word 'help' in
the subject or body (don't include the quotes), and you will get back a
message with instructions.
Send letters (Feedback, Inquiries & Information) to the editor to
terrie.lloyd at japaninc.com.
For more information on advertising in this newsletter, contact
ads at japaninc.com.
Get Terrie's Take by giving your name and email address at
http://www.japaninc.com/newsletters/free_sign_up, or go straight to
Mailman at: http://mailman.japaninc.com/mailman/listinfo/terrie
Copyright 2017 Japan Inc. Communications Inc.
----------------- Japan Inc opens up Japan ----------------
J at pan Inc authoritatively chronicles business trends in Japan. Each
posting brings you in-depth analysis of business, people and technology
in the world's third largest economy.
Visit www.japaninc.com for the best business insight on Japan available.
More information about the Terrie