Terrie's Take 933 (Tourism Edition) - Kyoto: Overcrowded and Unpleasant - Something Needs to be Done
terrie at mailman.japaninc.com
Mon Feb 26 09:52:30 JST 2018
* * * * * * * * TERRIE'S (TOURISM) TAKE - BY TERRIE LLOYD * * * * * *
A bi-weekly focused look at the tourism sector in Japan, by Terrie
Lloyd, a long-term technology and media entrepreneur living in Japan.
Tourism Sector Edition Sunday, Feb 25, 2018, Issue No. 933
SUBSCRIBE to, UNSUBSCRIBE from Terrie's Take at:
+++ Kyoto: Overcrowded and Unpleasant - Something Needs to be Done
As I write this, I am returning on a Nozomi shinkansen after doing a
speaking engagement in Kyoto for the orphans organization Ashinaga
(better known as "Daddy Long Legs"). While in Kyoto, I spent a day
visiting some major tourist destinations, to get a feel for how things
have changed over the last couple of years, particularly how Japan's
premier tourist destination is coping with the masses of foreign
visitors. And what masses there were. On some streets, such as Shijo
Dori in Gion, less than half those cramming the sidewalks were Japanese.
There is no formal estimate of how many foreign tourists are visiting
Kyoto each year, although the number actually staying is known and was
3.16m people in 2015. Given the increases in national tourism, and Kyoto
certainly follows the trend, we can guesstimate that about 7m foreign
visitors stayed in Kyoto in 2017. In addition, there are the many
tourists who stay in outlying areas and Osaka and Nagoya, then travel in
to see the sights for the day. Our guess is that this increases the
number of foreigners on the streets to around 12m a year. Surprisingly,
this is still only about 25% of the number of Japanese visiting the city
annually, but then the Japanese are probably there for business and
The flood of tourists has been good economically for Kyoto, with an
estimated JPY1trn (now likely to be around JPY2.5trn) being spent there
annually. You can see the effects of the cash, with a tremendous amount
of new building, loads of new European luxury cars on the road, and
well-stocked high-end stores in the main shopping areas. If you're a
merchant and you live outside the city center, you're a happy camper.
The unhappy campers are those residents living downtown, especially
those around major attractions such as the big temples, and Gion and
Pontocho. Here, the press of humanity is unrelenting, the grinding sound
of suitcase wheels fills the streets, and even getting in the car to go
to the supermarket is a challenge. Apparently the number of residents in
Higashiyama Ward, home to Kodaiji and Sanjusangendo, has fallen from
80,000 twenty years ago to around 40,000 today. And, unfortunately for
everyone, those left in the area are defensive, grumpy, old people who
hate tourists. They are also the same people who have caused Kyoto to
effectively block Airbnb in their area (Kyoto is mooting allowing Airbnb
only during January and February each year!).
--------- From Veggie Burgers to Carrot Cake --------------
Our commitment at Alishan Organics is to give our customers the best of
western organic foods, but prepared with a Japanese twist. That's why
our menus cover such a broad range of styles and tastes. If you're just
getting to know us, why not visit our cafe by the river in Saitama? That
way you can try out a variety of dishes and decide for yourself. Choose
from an Amy's organic pizza straight from the oven, a mouthwatering
veggie burger packed with seasonal greens and reds, or if you're feeling
chilly, a filling vegetable curry with rice. And although we're healthy
minded, we don't skimp on desserts. Favorites include Jack's scrumptious
carrot cake, vegan brownies (of course with vegan icecream), and baked
banana cheese cake.
Our Cafe: http://bit.ly/2m0r8z7
Our new online store: http://bit.ly/2v8gRpi
----- Snowshoeing in Minakami, Gunma, 11th March 2018 -----
www.JapanTravel.com is organizing a small-group day trip to Gunma
prefecture, where you will traverse the snowy, mountainous region of
Minakami via snowshoes! Be led by a certified English-speaking mountain
guide who will assist you in navigating the terrain. After that, move on
to the beautiful Takaragawa Onsen for a soak in the hot springs beside
the river, before heading back to Tokyo!
Snow wear and equipment is required for the trip - you can either bring
your own, or rent with JapanTravel.
Shop the experience here: https://goo.gl/6TsThX
As I walked around, I witnessed a growing impatience and rudeness by
Kyoto residents towards tourists that was both embarrassing and
concerning. Along the flagstoned Hanamikoji Dori, joining Gion's main
shopping street of Shijo Dori with Kenninji, I saw a bunch of old
rent-a-cops obviously employed by the local neighborhood association,
shooing tourists over to one side of the road. While ostensibly this
clearing of a public roadway for local cars is a good thing, the way
they were doing it was both imperious and irritated, and without logic
(i.e., no cars should mean no, or less, shoo-ing).
Those cars that did use the road were mostly not from the neighborhood
and were seeking a short-cut to a nearby main road that was choked with
traffic, or they were delivery trucks. Which should have priority? The
thousands of tourists an hour flooding into Kenninji at JPY500 each,
making the temple the single biggest employer in the neighborhood? Or
the delivery trucks? In any case, the behavior of the car drivers was
low-grade, with frequent honking, revving of engines, sudden starting
and stopping, and other signs of irritation. On witnessing this, I
wondered if the council couldn't simply shut down the road to
thru-traffic, or alternatively put full-time barriers in to separate
people from cars.
It seems to me that the city authorities are trying to patch over the
problem than to fix it.
Another function of the city that has been heavily criticized in the
press recently is the public transport. For more than 40 years, ever
since the city did away with their highly efficient street trams in the
1970's in favor of the new social symbol - the car - older locals have
been using buses to get around. To be sure there is effective rail
transport in Kyoto as well, but unfortunately there has been no new
building of subways in decades, so most of the city is not serviced by
The buses are great in their coverage, though, and are relatively
frequent. The problem is that they also service the major tourist sights
and so naturally tourists are using them. Unfortunately, with tourists
being forced to lug around heavy bags (not enough large lockers in
downtown Kyoto) and being unfamiliar with the Kyoto custom of boarding
from the back and alighting from the front, buses are now becoming a
nightmare to ride after 10:00am, around the time that the old folks who
rely on them, want to catch one. The net result is as you can imagine,
one of irritation, harsh words, and lots of complaints to city officials
about those "damned tourists".
To their credit, the Kyoto bus operators have been tinkering with their
systems to see if they can't improve the situation. For example, they
will change the bus loading system so that people can prepay at the
front and alight from the back, the way it's done in Tokyo. They will
also introduce flat fares, so that tourists can get their change ready
But the reality is that the overcrowding of Kyoto is a macro problem
that needs to be solved both by the central government and the local
Kyoto authorities. What's important in solving the problem is that they
don't kill the golden goose. Some initiatives that I believe would help
to improve the situation include:
* Changing the traffic patterns around national cultural heritage sites
(mostly the major temples) to give priority to pedestrians. Yes, this
will create some hardship for the locals, but providing them with
special passes while denying access to thru-traffic and delivery trucks,
would significantly reduce the need to control the pedestrian flow.
* Banning non-essential cars from downtown Kyoto between the hours of
10:00-18:00. Only delivery trucks, tradesmen, public transport, and
emergency vehicles should have access.
* Increasing the number of buses (of course)
* Instead of spending money on a ridiculously expensive maglev train
from Tokyo to Nagoya, put some national funds into building several more
badly needed subway lines.
* Engaging in some badly needed customer-service education of the
rent-a-cops and other people tasked with interacting with tourists on
* Increasing the salary requirement for visas for inbound Chinese
tourists, to slow the flow of rural visitors (not saying all Chinese
tourists are undesirable, but unfortunately rural visitors have few
public manners - spitting, toilet use, trash, etc.).
* Perhaps most importantly, the Japanese government needs to fund some
alternative destinations to Kyoto. Why tourists make a beeline for Kyoto
is because of the prevalence of historical buildings and entire
precincts in pristine condition. Funding should be made available to
help the beautification and rebuilding of older precincts of other
cities around the nation. Akita, Sendai, Kanazawa, Kochi, Matsuyama, and
Kumamoto are cities that all come to mind.
...The information janitors/
---------- Bilingual vet clinic opens in Azabu ------------
PetLife Veterinary Clinic is opening its doors in central Tokyo from
March, providing bilingual (Japanese/English) services for both the
domestic and international communities. The clinic provides experienced
veterinarians with many years of experience serving families and their
pets using the latest technology. They have a compassionate and welcome
approach and aim to nurture close bonds within the local community.
The official opening is March 6, however a three-day open clinic event
will be held Mar 2 - 4 including a special day for international
residents Mar 3. Pet owners are welcome to come visit and check out the
1F. Daiichi Bldg., 2-3-5 Higashi Azabu, Minato-ku, Tokyo 106-0044.
TEL:03-6807-4058 Website: http://petlife.co.jp/en/
SUBSCRIBERS: 6,335 members as of Feb 25, 2018 (We purge our list regularly.)
+++ ABOUT US
Written by: Terrie Lloyd (terrie.lloyd at japaninc.com)
HELP: E-mail Terrie-request at mailman.japaninc.com with the word 'help' in
the subject or body (don't include the quotes), and you will get back a
message with instructions.
Send letters (Feedback, Inquiries & Information) to the editor to
terrie.lloyd at japaninc.com.
For more information on advertising in this newsletter, contact
ads at japaninc.com.
Get Terrie's Take by giving your name and email address at
http://www.japaninc.com/newsletters/free_sign_up, or go straight to
Mailman at: http://mailman.japaninc.com/mailman/listinfo/terrie
Copyright 2018 Japan Inc. Communications Inc.
----------------- Japan Inc opens up Japan ----------------
J at pan Inc authoritatively chronicles business trends in Japan. Each
posting brings you in-depth analysis of business, people and technology
in the world's third largest economy.
Visit www.japaninc.com for the best business insight on Japan available.
More information about the Terrie